How do Barnes and Maddison compare?

Barnes has more season points (42 vs 14), Barnes is more owned (7.4% vs 0.6%), Barnes is cheaper (6.1m vs 6.2m), Barnes has the higher Start rate (100% vs 22%), Barnes has more Bonus (3 vs 2), but Maddison has easier upcoming fixtures (average fixture difficulty 2.80 vs 3.20).

← Back to players Pick different players

Hide stats where they're level

Comparing 2 midfielders

Barnes wins most stats

Newcastle

NEW · 6.1m

25 stats won

Spurs

TOT · 6.2m

6 stats won

Who wins more stats: Barnes or Maddison?

Barnes wins 25 of 31 stats

Barnes wins 25 of the 31 stats with an outright best. Others: Maddison 6.

Points: Barnes: 42Maddison: 14
xGI (6 gw): Barnes: 0.37Maddison: 0.04
Price: Barnes: £6.1mMaddison: £6.2m

Which sections does each player win?

Stats won by each player, by section
Section	Barnes	Maddison
Price & ownership	2	1
Playing time	4	0
Recent form	5	1
Season totals	6	0
Set pieces	1	1
Bonus	3	1
Fixtures	0	1
FPL ranks	4	1
Total	25	6

A stat counts when one player is strictly best. Ties and availability are not counted.

How do their key stats compare?

Each spoke is scaled against the best MID in the game. Hover for values.

Barnes: Points 42, xGI (6 gw) 0.37, BPS 167, Mins (6 gw) 88, DC (6 gw) 5.8, Upcoming FDR 3.20. Maddison: Points 14, xGI (6 gw) 0.04, BPS 75, Mins (6 gw) 29, DC (6 gw) 3.8, Upcoming FDR 2.80.

A tick marks the best value. Grey figures show how far each other player is from it.

Who is more expensive and more owned?

Barnes leads 2 of 3

Who is more expensive and more owned?
Stat	Barnes	Maddison
Price	6.1m−0.1m vs best	6.2m(best)
Ownership	7.4%(best)	0.6%−6.8% vs best

Top 10k ownership	11.6%(best)	0.3%−11.3% vs best

Availability	Available	Available

See alsoTop 10k ownership

Who starts and plays more minutes?

Barnes leads 4 of 4

Who starts and plays more minutes?
Stat	Barnes	Maddison
Starts	9(best)	2−7 vs best

Start rate	100%(best)	22%−78% vs best

Minutes (season)	796(best)	193−603 vs best

Avg minutes	88(best)	21−67 vs best

Who has better recent form?

Barnes leads 5 of 6

Who has better recent form?
Stat	Barnes	Maddison
Mins (6 gw)	88(best)	29−59 vs best

xG (6 gw)	0.22(best)	0.03−0.19 vs best

xA (6 gw)	0.15(best)	0.01−0.14 vs best

xGI (6 gw)	0.37(best)	0.04−0.33 vs best

DC (6 gw)	5.83(best)	3.83−2.00 vs best

xGC (6 gw) · lower is better	1.73+1.50 vs best	0.23(best)

Who has scored more this season?

Barnes leads 6 of 6

Who has scored more this season?
Stat	Barnes	Maddison
Points	42(best)	14−28 vs best

Goals	2(best)	1−1 vs best

Assists	3(best)	0−3 vs best

Total xG	1.54(best)	0.16−1.38 vs best

Total xA	0.96(best)	0.10−0.86 vs best

DC (season)	53(best)	25−28 vs best

See alsoMidfielder stat leaders

Who takes the set pieces?

Split

Who takes the set pieces?
Stat	Barnes	Maddison
Corners & indirect FKs	4th choice(best)	5th choice
Direct free kicks	—	5th choice(best)
Penalties	—	—
Penalties missed · lower is better	0	0

Who is collecting more bonus?

Barnes leads 3 of 4

Who is collecting more bonus?
Stat	Barnes	Maddison
BPS	167(best)	75−92 vs best

BPS (6 gw)	18.2(best)	11.5−6.7 vs best

Bonus	3(best)	2−1 vs best

Bonus (6 gw)	0.2−0.1 vs best	0.3(best)

Who has easier upcoming fixtures?

Maddison leads 1 of 1

Who has easier upcoming fixtures?
Stat	Barnes	Maddison
Next 5 GWs	FUL (A) 10 ARS (H) 11 BHA (A) 12 MUN (H) 13 SUN (H) 14	LEE (A) 10 IPS (H) 11 SUN (A) 12 FUL (H) 13 ARS (H) 14
Avg FDR · lower is better	3.20+0.40 vs best	2.80(best)

See alsoSeason calendar Team rating Projected goals and clean sheet probability

How do their official FPL ranks compare?

Barnes leads 4 of 5

How do their official FPL ranks compare?
Stat	Barnes	Maddison
Form	3.5(best) 35th MID · 85th overall	2.8 57th MID · 137th overall
ICT index	54.1(best) 20th MID · 27th overall	15.9 110th MID · 232nd overall
Selected	14th MID(best) 46th overall	75th MID 224th overall
Points per game	4.7(best) 20th MID · 49th overall	2.3 101st MID · 233rd overall
Cost rank	43rd MID 63rd overall	37th MID(best) 55th overall

What do the bookies expect from their next fixtures?

BarnesNEW
1. NEW v FUL away, gameweek 10: 1.12 projected goals, 21% clean sheet chance
2. NEW v ARS home, gameweek 11: 0.89 projected goals, 17% clean sheet chance
MaddisonTOT
1. TOT v LEE away, gameweek 10: 1.16 projected goals, 31% clean sheet chance
2. TOT v IPS home, gameweek 11: 1.82 projected goals, 41% clean sheet chance

Over their next 2 fixtures: Maddison (TOT) 3.0 projected team goals, Barnes (NEW) 2.0 projected team goals.

Team projections from bookmaker odds; shaded by projected goals. All projections

Who is over- or under-performing their expected stats?

Goals vs xG

Barnes+0.5Barnes: 2 goals from 1.54 xG (+0.5)
Maddison+0.8Maddison: 1 goals from 0.16 xG (+0.8)

Maddison has 0.8 more goals than xG.

Assists vs xA

Barnes+2.0Barnes: 3 assists from 0.96 xA (+2.0)
Maddison−0.1Maddison: 0 assists from 0.10 xA (−0.1)

Barnes has 2.0 more assists than xA.

Where do their FPL points come from?

Barnes · 42 pts43% from appearances
Maddison · 14 pts50% from appearances

Season points by source
Source	Barnes	Maddison
Appearances	18	7
Goals	10	5
Assists	9	0
Clean sheets	2	0
Bonus	3	2
Deductions	0	0
Total	42	14

Worked out match by match from FPL's scoring rules; deductions are what's left against FPL's total.

Who scores against good teams?

Easy (FDR 1–2)

Barnes6.3(3)
Maddison9.0(1)

Medium (FDR 3)

Barnes4.2(5)
Maddison1.0(3)

Hard (FDR 4–5)

Barnes2.0(1)
Maddison1.0(2)

Points per game in matches played (games in brackets). Against hard opponents: Barnes 2.0 points per game, Maddison 1.0 points per game.

Who is better at home, and who away?

Home

Barnes5.4(5)
Maddison3.7(3)

Away

Barnes3.8(4)
Maddison1.0(3)

Points per game in matches played (games in brackets). Away from home: Barnes 3.8 points per game, Maddison 1.0 points per game.

Barnes42%
2 goals and 3 assists of 12 NEW goals
Maddison13%
1 goal and 0 assists of 8 TOT goals

Barnes is involved in 42% of NEW's goals, against 13% for Maddison.

Who is a rotation risk?

Barnes8 of 9 full games
8 × 90 minutes, 1 × 60–89
Maddison0 of 9 full games
1 × 60–89, 5 × 1–59, 3 × Didn't play

Is each player a creator or a goal threat?

Influence

Barnes164.4
Maddison75.2

Creativity

Barnes185.0
Maddison42.1

Threat

Barnes192.0
Maddison41.0

FPL's season ICT scores. Barnes's biggest score is threat, a goal threat; Maddison's biggest score is influence, an all-round influence.

Who are managers buying this gameweek?

Barnes−16.1k25.0k out8.9k in
Maddison+3652.1k out2.4k in

Maddison has the most net transfers in this gameweek (+365).

Which player gives more points per million?

Every MID who has played, by price and season points. Above the line is better value than the median.

Of 218 midfielders who have played: Barnes 6.9 points per £m (11th), Maddison 2.3 points per £m (119th). Median 2.5.

How have their stats tracked by gameweek?

From To

Barnes
Maddison

Who has scored more points over these gameweeks?

Points over GW 4 to 9: Barnes 25, Maddison 13.

How far ahead is Barnes? Above zero Barnes leads; below, Maddison.

Barnes is 12 points ahead of Maddison over these gameweeks. Barnes's biggest lead was 12 (GW 9).

Who hauls more often, and who blanks?

GW 4
Barnes, gameweek 4: 2 points v LEE away, 90 minutes
Maddison, gameweek 4: 1 points v EVE home, 13 minutes
GW 5
Barnes, gameweek 5: 9 points v HUL home, 90 minutes
Maddison, gameweek 5: 1 points v AVL home, 24 minutes
GW 6
Barnes, gameweek 6: 2 points v COV away, 90 minutes
Maddison, gameweek 6: 1 points v MUN away, 16 minutes
GW 7
Barnes, gameweek 7: 2 points v AVL home, 90 minutes
Maddison, gameweek 7: 9 points v COV home, 68 minutes
GW 8
Barnes, gameweek 8: 8 points v CRY away, 76 minutes
Maddison, gameweek 8: 1 points v CHE away, 50 minutes
GW 9
Barnes, gameweek 9: 2 points v EVE home, 90 minutes
Maddison, gameweek 9: 0 points v CRY home, 0 minutes

Barnes: 0 hauls (10+), 4 blanks (0–2); Maddison: 0 hauls (10+), 5 blanks (0–2).

Points

Values by gameweek

Points by gameweek
GW	Barnes	Maddison
4	2	1
5	9	1
6	2	1
7	2	9
8	8	1
9	2	0

Minutes

Values by gameweek

Minutes by gameweek
GW	Barnes	Maddison
4	90	13
5	90	24
6	90	16
7	90	68
8	76	50
9	90	0

Expected goals (xG)

Values by gameweek

Expected goals (xG) by gameweek
GW	Barnes	Maddison
4	0.29	0.00
5	0.11	0.06
6	0.35	0.00
7	0.27	0.10
8	0.27	0.00
9	0.03	0.00

Expected assists (xA)

Values by gameweek

Expected assists (xA) by gameweek
GW	Barnes	Maddison
4	0.31	0.01
5	0.11	0.02
6	0.35	0.01
7	0.04	0.04
8	0.01	0.01
9	0.08	0.00

Expected goal involvements (xGI)

Values by gameweek

Expected goal involvements (xGI) by gameweek
GW	Barnes	Maddison
4	0.60	0.01
5	0.22	0.08
6	0.70	0.01
7	0.31	0.14
8	0.28	0.01
9	0.11	0.00

Defensive contribution

Values by gameweek

Defensive contribution by gameweek
GW	Barnes	Maddison
4	6	3
5	9	6
6	7	4
7	3	6
8	6	4
9	4	0

Goals

Values by gameweek

Goals by gameweek
GW	Barnes	Maddison
4	0	0
5	0	0
6	0	0
7	0	1
8	1	0
9	0	0

Assists

Values by gameweek

Assists by gameweek
GW	Barnes	Maddison
4	0	0
5	2	0
6	0	0
7	0	0
8	0	0
9	0	0

Ownership

Values by gameweek

Ownership by gameweek
GW	Barnes	Maddison
4	2.7%	0.4%
5	4.6%	0.4%
6	8.5%	0.4%
7	8.0%	0.4%
8	7.4%	0.5%
9	7.6%	0.6%

Price

Values by gameweek

Price by gameweek
GW	Barnes	Maddison
4	£6.0m	£6.3m
5	£6.0m	£6.3m
6	£6.1m	£6.3m
7	£6.1m	£6.2m
8	£6.1m	£6.2m
9	£6.1m	£6.2m

Top 10k ownership

Values by gameweek

Top 10k ownership by gameweek
GW	Barnes	Maddison
4	—	—
5	16.8%	0.0%
6	15.6%	0.0%
7	12.9%	0.0%
8	18.0%	0.1%
9	11.6%	0.3%